Aircraft Safety

Are Experimental Airplanes More Dangerous?

Back to Blog List

Most buyers shop the design and ignore the builder, and that one habit explains more of the safety gap than anything in the airframe. A clean-looking kit plane with a sloppy fuel system or an untested engine installation can cost you an off-airport landing in the first 20 hours, and it can cost your estate far more than the purchase price. The question of whether experimental amateur-built airplanes are more dangerous than certified ones has a real answer in the accident data, and it is more useful than a yes or no: the risk is concentrated in a handful of specific, checkable places.

This article walks you through those places one at a time, so you can look at a particular airplane on a particular ramp and judge it instead of judging the whole category.

Start With the Numbers, Not the Reputation

The headline statistic is real, and you should know it before you argue about it. In its 2012 safety study on amateur-built aircraft (NTSB/SS-12/01), the National Transportation Safety Board found that experimental amateur-built airplanes made up roughly 10 percent of the U.S. general aviation fleet but accounted for about 15 percent of all GA accidents and about 21 percent of the fatal ones in the year studied. AOPA's Air Safety Institute has reported a similar pattern in its annual Joseph T. Nall Report ever since: measured per flight hour, experimental aircraft have carried an accident rate several times that of certified personal airplanes, with the fatal rate running roughly two to three times higher depending on the year and the slice of data.

But a category rate is an average of thousands of very different airplanes, built by thousands of very different people. It tells you almost nothing about the one you are standing next to. Think of it like a used house built by an owner-contractor: the floor plan may be proven and the lumber may be fine, but the wiring is only as good as the person who ran it.

  • Look up the specific type in the NTSB's CAROL accident database. Good answer: a popular design with hundreds flying and an accident list dominated by fuel exhaustion and landing mishaps. Bad answer: a short production run with repeated in-flight breakups or control-system failures.
  • Count how many are flying. Good: a type with a thousand-plus completions, an active builder community and a factory still shipping parts. Bad: a one-off or a design with fewer than 50 examples and no support.
  • Separate design problems from pilot problems. Good: the fatal accidents you find involve weather, low-level maneuvering or fuel management — pilot-side issues you control. Bad: a cluster of the same mechanical failure across unrelated airframes.
  • Check whether the type is insurable. Good: two or three carriers will quote hull coverage at your experience level. Bad: nobody will write hull, which is the market telling you something.

Why It Matters: Experimental aircraft fly a different mission mix than the certified fleet. More aerobatics, more low-level formation, more first flights, more weekend fun flying and far fewer IFR cross-countries. Some of the rate gap is the flying, not the airplane.

Where the Risk Clusters: Phase I and the First 40 Hours

The NTSB's single most actionable finding was about timing. Accidents in amateur-built aircraft bunch up heavily at the very start of an airframe's life — first flights and early test hours — and then bunch up again right after the airplane changes hands from the builder to a new owner. A brand-new experimental is at its most dangerous in the hours before anyone has proved it works.

Every amateur-built aircraft receives operating limitations establishing its Phase I flight test requirements. The traditional approach uses a minimum of 25 hours with an eligible type-certificated engine and propeller combination, or 40 hours otherwise. However, the FAA also permits an optional task-based flight test program under Advisory Circular 90-89C when authorized by the aircraft's operating limitations. Under this approach, the test period is completed by demonstrating the required flight characteristics and completing the prescribed test tasks rather than simply accumulating a fixed number of hours. The aircraft must satisfy its operating limitations and have the required Phase I completion entry before beginning normal Phase II operations.

  • Find the Phase I completion logbook entry. Good: a dated entry with the required language stating the aircraft has been shown to be controllable throughout its normal range of speeds and maneuvers. Bad: no entry, vague wording, or hours that do not match the tach.
  • Ask who flew off the test period. Good: the builder with time in type, or a hired test pilot, following a written plan based on FAA Advisory Circular 90-89, the agency's flight testing handbook for amateur-built aircraft. Bad: "a friend took it around the pattern a few times."
  • Read the actual operating limitations document. Good: present, legible, matching the airframe, with the test area and restrictions clearly stated. Bad: lost. Replacing it means going back to the FAA or a DAR.
  • Compare total time to what the logs claim. Good: a few hundred hours flown steadily over several years. Bad: 42 hours in six years, meaning the airplane has barely been shaken out and has sat.

Good to Know: Since 2015 the FAA has allowed a qualified second pilot in the cockpit during Phase I under Advisory Circular 90-116, the Additional Pilot Program. A test period flown that way, with a briefed plan and a second set of eyes, is a meaningful quality signal in the logbook.

Flying411 keeps experimental and certified listings in one place, so you can compare a 200-hour RV against a 1970s certified single without flipping between a dozen sites.

The Builder Matters More Than the Design

Two airframes from the same kit, same serial-number range, same engine, can be wildly different airplanes. One was built by a retired machinist who photographed every rib and called an EAA technical counselor three times. The other was finished in a hurry by the third owner of a half-done project. The FAA's amateur-built rule, 14 CFR 21.191(g), only requires that the major portion be built for education or recreation. It says nothing about skill.

  • Ask for the builder's log. Good: a bound or digital log with dated entries, photographs of the internal structure before it was closed up, and receipts for the kit and major components. Bad: a thin folder assembled the week the airplane went up for sale.
  • Find out how many owners it has had and how many builders. Good: one builder, start to finish. Bad: a project that passed through two or three hands mid-build, where nobody can tell you who torqued what.
  • Check whether the builder is still reachable. Good: a phone number and a willingness to answer questions about the wiring and the fuel system. Bad: deceased or unreachable, with no documentation to replace him.
  • Look at the quality tells. Good: consistent rivet lines, clean safety wire, labeled wire bundles, chafe protection where lines pass through bulkheads. Bad: mismatched hardware, hardware-store bolts, electrical tape, or a panel wired in a rainbow of unlabeled wire.
  • Ask about EAA technical counselor visits. Good: multiple documented visits during the build. Bad: none, and the builder did not know the program existed.

Heads Up: The aircraft-specific repairman certificate under 14 CFR Section 65.104 belongs to the original qualifying builder and does not transfer when the airplane is sold. However, the FAA's MOSAIC changes now allow an appropriately rated light-sport repairman to perform the annual condition inspection on an experimental amateur-built aircraft they own, provided its operating limitations authorize it. Otherwise, the inspection must be signed by an appropriately authorized A&P mechanic or the aircraft's original repairman certificate holder. Check the aircraft's operating limitations before budgeting for annual inspection costs.

Powerplant and Fuel System

Engine failure shows up far more often in amateur-built accident reports than in certified ones, and it is rarely the engine itself breaking. It is the installation: fuel feed, fuel selectors, induction air, cooling, and ignition systems that were never tested across the full flight envelope. Our guide to experimental diesel aircraft engines covers one end of the alternative-powerplant spectrum; the same scrutiny applies to any non-traditional installation.

  • Identify the engine exactly. Good: a standard Lycoming or Continental, or a factory-supported Rotax 912-series, with a data plate and its own logbook. Bad: an auto conversion with a homemade reduction drive and no service history.
  • Confirm applicable AD requirements on installed components. Airworthiness Directives generally apply to type-certificated products, but their applicability to engines, propellers and appliances installed on experimental aircraft depends on the specific AD wording. Under FAA Advisory Circular 39-7D, an AD must be checked to determine whether it covers non-type-certificated aircraft or components installed on them. Good: a documented review of applicable ADs and related safety recommendations. Bad: an owner who assumes experimental status means every AD can be ignored.
  • Ask how the fuel system was tested. Good: documented unusable-fuel and fuel-flow testing at the critical attitude, as AC 90-89 describes, with results written down. Bad: no record, and a tank-selector arrangement the owner cannot explain in one sentence.
  • Check the ignition setup. Good: dual mags, or one mag plus one electronic ignition with a documented backup power plan. Bad: dual electronic ignition fed by a single battery and no alternate source.
  • Look at the fuel lines and firewall penetrations. Good: firesleeved hoses with legible date tags, fire-rated pass-throughs, nothing rubbing. Bad: rubber hose clamped to barbed fittings, or hoses older than ten years with no replacement entry.

Pro Tip: Ask to see the airplane started cold, then pull the cowling within five minutes of shutdown. Fresh fuel weeping, oil mist on the firewall and heat-damaged wiring all show up far better on a hot engine than on a cold one.

The Pilot Side of the Statistic

The NTSB study flagged something uncomfortable: a disproportionate share of amateur-built accidents involved pilots who had recently bought the airplane from someone else. A slick composite single that cruises at 180 knots and touches down at 70 behaves nothing like the trainer most buyers come from, and the transition is where people get hurt. Loss of control in flight remains the leading fatal category across the experimental fleet.

  • Get type-specific transition training before the first solo flight. Good: several hours with an instructor who actually flies the type, in that type. Bad: a quick checkout from the seller in the right seat with no dual controls.
  • Match the airplane to your hours honestly. Good: a 200-hour private pilot buying a docile, forgiving design. Bad: the same pilot buying a short-coupled, high-wing-loading racer because it is fast.
  • Check the landing gear configuration against your logbook. Many popular kits are taildraggers. Good: a current tailwheel endorsement and recent time. Bad: planning to get the endorsement in the airplane you just bought. Our roundup of the best tailwheel airplanes for your endorsement is a better starting point.
  • Get an insurance quote before you sign anything. Good: a carrier quotes you with a reasonable dual requirement. Bad: a refusal, or a hull deductible so large the coverage is decorative.

Flying411 keeps experimental listings searchable by type and hours, so you can see how many RV-7s, RV-10s and Sonex airframes are actually trading before you commit to a design.

Maintenance, Records and Paperwork

A certified airplane carries a paper trail the FAA designed. An experimental carries whatever the builder and owners chose to keep. That freedom is a genuine advantage in cost — you can do your own work, use non-PMA parts and install the avionics you want — and a genuine risk when the records are thin. If you want a model of what good documentation looks like on a specific type, our walkthrough of buying a Van's RV-6A goes through the logs page by page.

  • Verify the annual condition inspection entries. Good: one every twelve calendar months, signed by an appropriately authorized A&P, the aircraft-specific repairman certificate holder, or an eligible light-sport repairman where the operating limitations permit. The entry should contain the required inspection wording and certificate information. Bad: missing inspections, incomplete entries or signatures from someone without the required authority.
  • Confirm the registration and airworthiness certificate on the FAA registry. Good: N-number, serial number and owner all match, with a special airworthiness certificate in the experimental amateur-built category. Bad: a mismatch, or a certificate issued in a different experimental category such as exhibition.
  • Ask for the weight and balance. Good: an actual weighing record with dates, plus an updated sheet after any major change. Bad: numbers copied from the kit manual.
  • Review the avionics installation. Good: a wiring diagram, current transponder inspections under 14 CFR Section 91.413 when applicable, and altimeter and static-system inspections under Section 91.411 for IFR operations in controlled airspace. Both inspections generally have 24-calendar-month intervals. Check that any required ADS-B Out equipment is properly installed and functioning. Bad: a beautiful glass panel with no wiring documentation, expired required inspections or unresolved equipment problems.
  • Get a pre-buy from someone who knows the type. Good: a shop or type-club inspector with experience on that airframe. Bad: the seller's own mechanic, or no pre-buy at all because "it's experimental, there's nothing to inspect."

Keep in Mind: Roughly 700 to 1,000 new amateur-built aircraft are certificated in the United States each year, and the registered fleet sits around 33,000 airframes. That is a large, mature market with real type clubs behind the popular designs — Van's alone has more than 10,000 completed aircraft flying. Obscure one-offs are the exception, not the rule.

The Checklist at a Glance

What to checkWhat good looks likeRed flag
Type accident historyAccidents dominated by pilot-side causes; hundreds flyingRepeated structural or control failures across airframes
Phase I completionDated completion entry documenting compliance with the aircraft's authorized hours-based or task-based flight test programMissing entry or unexplained discrepancies in flight-test records
Operating limitationsOriginal document present and matching the airframeLost; needs FAA or DAR reissue
Builder logDated entries, in-progress photos, kit and parts receiptsThin folder assembled at sale time
Number of buildersOne builder start to finish, still reachableProject passed through several hands mid-build
EngineCertificated Lycoming, Continental or supported Rotax with its own logAuto conversion, homemade PSRU, no history
AD complianceReview of applicable ADs for installed engines, propellers and appliances, including experimental-aircraft applicabilityNo AD review or blanket assumptions about experimental exemptions
Fuel system testingDocumented flow and unusable-fuel testing per AC 90-89No record; selector logic the owner cannot explain
Condition inspectionsEvery 12 calendar months, signed by an appropriately authorized mechanic or repairmanGaps, unsigned entries or an unauthorized inspector
Weight and balanceActual weighing record, updated after modificationsFigures copied from the kit manual
Transition trainingInstructor experienced in type available and scheduledPlan to teach yourself after the ferry flight
InsuranceHull and liability quoted at your experience levelNo carrier will write hull coverage

Before You Sign

Walk away when the paperwork cannot be reconstructed. A missing operating limitations document, no builder log and no traceable engine history are not small problems you fix later — they shrink your buyer pool when you sell and they leave you guessing about systems you cannot see. Walk away, too, from any airplane where the seller's answer to a specific question about the fuel system or the ignition is a shrug. On a certified airplane, someone at the factory made those decisions and documented them. On an experimental, the only record is the one the builder kept.

Get a professional opinion whenever the type is unfamiliar to you, whenever the engine is anything other than a standard certificated or factory-supported installation, and whenever the price is high enough that a mistake hurts. Type clubs are the cheapest expertise in aviation — many maintain pre-buy checklists specific to the design. If the asking price is unusual in either direction, a formal opinion of value is worth the fee; our guide on when a certified aircraft appraiser is worth it covers how that works. And if you are still weighing the whole category against a factory airplane, the cost side is laid out in our comparison of RV-10 vs SR22 ownership, while are small planes safer than big planes puts the general aviation rate in wider context.

So: are experimental amateur-built airplanes more dangerous than certified ones? As a fleet average, yes, and the data has said so consistently since the NTSB study. As an individual purchase, the average is close to meaningless. An eight-year-old, 600-hour kit plane with a certificated engine, a complete builder log, clean condition inspections and a new owner who gets ten hours of transition training is not the airplane in those statistics. The one that is has fewer than 50 hours, a novel engine, no paperwork and a pilot who has never flown anything like it.

Flying411 keeps amateur-built and factory-certified aircraft side by side in one searchable marketplace, so you can weigh hours, engine type and asking price without guessing.

When you are ready to compare listings, visitFlying411and see what is on the market today.